Carmines Pie House

frederick shields a month ago

Writing Carmine’s definitely knows how to make a pizza! 🍕 We started with the Cajun wings, and they were packed with flavor. Most of them were still nice and hot when they arrived, and I’d absolutely order them again. Then came the Chicago deep-pan pizza. It says it serves 2–3 people, but after those wings, you’ll probably only manage one slice 😂. If you’ve been to Chicago, this pizza comes pretty close to the real thing. We went with something similar to a meat lovers, and the crust was nice and crispy. The filling was loaded with all those delicious meaty flavors, topped with a rich red sauce and plenty of cheese. That cheese was cheesing! 😋 The pizza was truly filling, flavorful, and satisfying. I’d definitely recommend it to any pizza lover. The staff was great, the atmosphere was welcoming and LGBTQ+ friendly, and I’ll definitely be back! 🍕❤️

Glenn Wonnacott Edited a month ago

Delicious reminder of Chicago in North Florida. I can't remember the last time I had a good Italian Beef and it was massive! Second trip: My wife agrees! It was great and our server Richard was the best. Couldn't have been more attentive and seems like a guy I'd like to hang out with.

Sydney Mathis 3 months ago

Pizza was decent, too much sauce and felt hard to eat without fork and knife. They were also out of four beers out of the drafts on a weekend had to settle for a wheat beer. Flys seemed to be buzzing around frequently. It’s a cute local spot but didn’t quite fill my appetite.

MEL B 4 months ago

I ordered online here by mistake because I thought it was another pizza place, but I’m so happy I did because we found this awesome place! Everything was fresh and full of flavor. The pizza was loaded with cheese, and the calzone was amazing — a very thin layer of bread stuffed with cheese and ricotta. We absolutely loved it! Carmine's Pie House definitely exceeded our expectations, and we will absolutely be coming back! 🍕✨

George Smith 7 months ago

Had an amazing experience at Carmine’s Chicago Style Pizza! The pizza was the definition of true Chicago deep dish — incredibly thick, loaded edge-to-edge with toppings, and built in rich, hearty layers that made every bite feel like a full meal. The crust was perfectly buttery and sturdy enough to hold the generous mountain of cheese, sauce, and toppings without missing a beat. It was indulgent, satisfying, and absolutely unforgettable. Bailey made the night even better with her warm, attentive service and great personality. She kept everything flowing smoothly and made us feel genuinely taken care of. Between the phenomenal pizza and Bailey’s top-notch service, this place is a must-visit! I saw the wings coming out for other customers and they looked DELICIOUS!